Bad Cards

bad topic

There are some Cards which i really dislike.

1. Wooden Fence

This cards seem to me like a “copy” of the stone wall.

Better Wooden Fence:

def 1 hp 20
when wooden fence comes in play draw a card,

but then it is like wall of wisdom…… when i wrote this DarkRune added wall of wisdom i think….

2. Trebuchet
It would be much better if the Trebuchet could “shot”
0/0/10

2 Stone 56 sec : 10 damage to a building

These cards where meant to be improved, when the game-engine gets some more features:

• The Wooden Fence will become weaker (as you suggested), but it will occupy several spaces – link cloning itself to the fields at its right and left
• Trebuchet will get a Range of 2

aha ok,

there is another point:

we can create different kinds of “catapults”

highCost/highCooldown but a high range
or lowCost/lowCooldown but small range

which one should be the trebuchet?
was a trebuchet in the middle age a “high range” catapult?

In the real middle ages it was mainly a point of accuracy – not of range or damage. The problem was to hit at all :)

Trebuchets had a much better accuracy as catapults.

should the Trebuchet now be a highCost/highCooldown unit?
or not?

in a card game we should ignore accuracy,
a “50% chance to hit” effect would add to much random too FC
i think so.

should the Trebuchet now be a highCost/highCooldown unit?
or not?

I think it is fine as it, when it gets the range. Its medium cost, highCooldown. We could, however, give the Trebuchet range 3 and build a Catapult that does more damage but has only Range 2. We also would need to lower the Trebuchet-Damage in this case.

in a card game we should ignore accuracy,
a “50% chance to hit” effect would add to much random too FC
i think so.

That’s exactly what I thought.

do you think that a range of 7 would be OP?(overpowered)?
the elven archer has a range of 7 (i think that this is ok) so maybe the trebuchet should be range 7,too.

?

do you think that a range of 7 would be OP?(overpowered)?
the elven archer has a range of 7 (i think that this is ok) so maybe the trebuchet should be range 7,too.

I think a range of more than 2 for any of these units would be OP. The elven sniper isn’t bad because it only has a damage of 1.

These ranged units are going to be very strong because the map is so small. Midfield is only 1 rank wide, so I can activate a ranged unit in rank 3 of my kingdom and hit a unit in your kingdom still.

Imagine a unit with a range of 3 that I put in rank 2 behind my wall. This unit will be extremely hard to deal with when it has a 0/3/40 blocker in front of it, not to mention other units protecting it. This will be the strategy for these type of units.

hmm,

maybe you are right.
but I think that the elven sniper is not OP because his shot has a cost of wood, not because his damage is 1.

And you are right
this !should be the strategy of this units, a unique strategy only in FC.
I think if we can balance this, it would be a great expansion for strategies.

of course we can create both types of cards if we want.

I don’t think the cost is that big of a deal either though because wood is a very easy resource to acquire. If his damage was 2, then he would be OP because he could quickly take out some exchange/resource units.